Wednesday, January 9, 2013
When the tether of memory breaks.
The page which accident returned me to, is from the Monthly Review (a US publication) 1791. It's a review of Stewart's two books. Our anonymous correspondent appears to take great joy in offering an outline of Stewart's summation of national character. And I guess it interests me mostly because where I am still gainfully employed at the weekends, we are subject to a sensitivity training that frowns upon these sorts of dismissive remarks, even if sometimes they are unavoidable. Stewart's observations include the suggestion that the Poles were advancing in intellect, and that Lapland is the only asylum of liberty. Otherwise, the Irish are monsters, the Swiss are little better than the sheep they shear, the Danes and the Swedes are uncultivated. The English, though possessed of a high preeminence of thought were violent, hypocritical and corrupt. It goes on to include the terrible things Stewart had to say of the Spanish, the Portuguese, the Italians, the Russians, the Germans, the French, the United Provinces (or the Dutch, which I have to add here, because some modern readers of Stewart seem to think that in the 1790's United Provinces was Canada.) In 1791 Stewart had yet to reduce his visit to the United states into an opinion, so our American correspondent in the Monthly Review had no opportunity to add, or perhaps chose not to add, Stewart's opinion of The Americans to the list of infamy. Also interesting is that I didn't know Walking Stewart had been to Poland, let alone Lapland. And I am often suspicious of his claims. However a spy sent by His Majesty George the third's government did report back to his handler, that sometime in 1792, Stewart had "shipped to Norway." Spies are of course notoriously unreliable sources, suffering as they do from "the harpy hand of avarice."